By: James Ryan |
Saturday February 25, 2006 |
RatingNR FormatsDVD Genrehorror StarringSeiji Chihara, Yuka Hayashi, Sachiko Kokubu, Mizuho Nakamura, Masashi Taniguchi Directed byAtaru Oikawa PublisherPanik House Entertainment External Links |
A fundamental rule of storytelling is that plot is
created through conflict. Movies without conflict are
movies without plot. We have such experimental films,
many of which end up in museums rather than theaters
because they are made to be "viewed" rather than
"watched." We also have the occasional flick that
accidentally pushes the envelope of what might fairly
be considered plot by making its protagonist so
passive that there is never any real conflict at all.
Tokyo Psycho is such a film.
Yumiko Oosawa's (Sachiko Kokubu) life unravels when
she receives strange letters from a stalker. Her
stalker's aggressions escalate, and Yumiko eventually
finds herself alone with him on a remote part of the
coast where she must kill or be killed. This, in
itself, is not a bad premise for a horror film. If
Yumiko had any backbone at all, Tokyo Psycho
would have a suspenseful plot.
As it stands, however, this film is about as tense as
boiled cabbage. Poor Yumiko can't put up a fight (or
even run) though her life clearly depends on it. As
creepy letters pour in and get increasingly grotesque,
Yumiko uncovers clues about the identity of her
stalker. She then learns that her prime suspect, a
former classmate, is a known murderer and mentally ill
to boot.
Because the norms of the horror genre require that we
suspend disbelief when someone wanders into a dark
alleyway alone or fails to call the cops at the first
sign of trouble, we can forgive Yumiko for taking
almost no action in her own defense thus far.
However, when the psycho sits down at her kitchen
table, promises to marry her, giggles as he lacerates
his hand on a shard of her tea cup, and then
leaves, we expect her to get moving and do
something about her plight.
Instead, our "heroine" passively submits herself to
her stalker's bizarre fantasies. She is captured,
bagged, and taken to a picnic by the shore where the
psycho lovingly drizzles worms on her face. It is at
least possible that we are supposed to accept Tokyo
Psycho as a sort of "yuck-fest" whose purpose is
simply to make sure that each scene is grosser than
the last. If so, there is not enough "yuck" in this
film to make it stand out as a decent example of its
kind. Roth's Hostel is a better bet for
near-plotless gore.
In spite of its narrative flaws, Tokyo Psycho
manages to be watch-able. For better or worse,
Director Ataru Oikawa's adoption of the grainy,
handheld "realism" of our time lends a certain
credibility to performances that might otherwise seem
clumsy or exaggerated. Kokubu's performance is
pleasant enough; she pulls together a character that
we care about, even if we can't stand her passivity.
Though not exactly the true-crime horror it purports
to be, Tokyo Psycho is a Asian horror flick
based in human psychosis rather than supernatural
causes. Recommended only for those dedicated to the
genre and all its flops.