By: Michael Tatum |
Tuesday January 18, 2005 |
Genrer&b PublisherAlligator Records External Links |
The star of the Staples Singers is also at the heart of one of rock music's greatest
cinematic moments: when she steals the thunder from the Band's Levon Helm
and Rick Danko, giving her all on "The Weight" in The Last Waltz.
Certainly, the best of her Staples hits -- like "I'll Take You There" and
others showcased on Stax's 1975 best-of -- represent pop-gospel crossover
at its best. And even at 64, she's still in fine vocal form -- witness her
moving version of "Hard Times Come Again No More" on the recent compilation
Beautiful Dreamer: The Songs of Stephen Foster .
But this well regarded item is not where she makes a comeback. The problem isn't
necessarily her new folkie sideman-collaborators -- their mild studio funk
isn't overwhelming, but singers like Bonnie Raitt have done well in that
mode time and again. The problem is the sappy material they provide her
with -- you would never have known the mushily vague "In Times Like These"
was a tribute to two friends who died on 9/11 unless you happened to read
it in the liner notes. In such a bland context, battered warhorses like "A
Dying Man's Last Plea" and "Will the Circle Be Unbroken" -- both of which
Staples resuscitates and then some -- can only leap out of the speakers by
comparison.